Reviews on the Record

Following the disciplinary process, the Police Complaint Commissioner has the discretion to order a Review on the Record where there is a reasonable basis to believes that the decision of the Discipline Authority is incorrect or it is in the public interest to review the matter.

This type of review is where a retired judge is appointed to conduct a “paper review” of the entire matter, deliver a decision of whether there is misconduct and, if substantiated, determine the corrective and/or disciplinary measures to be imposed. The retired judge’s decision is final and conclusive.

Recommended Procedures (PDF)

 

Current Reviews on the Record

RR Members Departments Review on the Record Status
N/A N/A N/A No current Reviews on the Record

Concluded Reviews on the Record

RR Members Departments Adjudicator's Decision
RR 18-03Constable Byron RitchieDelta Police DepartmentNotice of Review on the Record
Constable Ritchie Submissions
Commission Counsel Submissions
Commission Counsel Supplemental Submissions
Adjudicator Threlfall Decision
RR 18-02Constable Geoffrey Young,
Delta Police DepartmentNotice of Review on the Record
Constable Young Submissions on Scope of Review on the Record
Commission Counsel Response on Scope of Review on the Record
Constable Young Reply Submission of Respondent Officer
Adjudicator Lazar Decision on Scope of Review on the Record
Constable Young Submissions to Call Further Evidence
Commission Counsel Response to Constable Young's Request to Submit Further Evidence
Adjudicator Lazar Decision on Constable Young Request to Submit New Evidence
Constable Young Submission on Discipline
Commission Counsel Reply on Submissions on Discipline
Adjudicator Lazor Decision
RR 18-01Special Municipal Constable KeithNew WestminsterNotice of Review on the Record
SMC Keith Submissions
Commission Counsel Submissions
Adjudicator Neal Decision
RR 16-04Constable Bunderla,
Constable O'Rourke
SCBCTAPSNotice of Review on the Record
Constable Bunderla and Constable O'Rourke Submissions on Scope of Review on the Record
Commission Counsel Response on Scope of Review on the Record
Adjudicator Oppal Decision on Scope of Review on the Record
Adjudicator Oppal Decision on Request for Recusal - Part 1
Adjudicator Oppal Decision on Request for Recusal - Part 2
Adjudicator Oppal Decision
RR 16-03Corporal McLaughlinWest VancouverNotice of Review on the Record
Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision
RR 16-02Constable GabrielVancouverNotice of Review on the Record
Supplementary Notice of Review on the Record
Constable Gabriel Submissions
Commission Counsel Submissions
Adjudicator Oppal Decision
RR 16-01Constable ThandiAbbotsfordNotice of Review on the Record
Constable Thandi Application to Call New Evidence
Commission Counsel Response to Application
Constable Thandi Response to Commission Counsel
Adjudicator McKinnon Ruling on Calling New Evidence
Constable Thandi Submissions
Commission Counsel Submissions
Adjudicator McKinnon Decision
RR 15-02Constable BatiukSCBCTAPSNotice of Review on the Record
Constable Batiuk Submissions
Commission Counsel Submissions
Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision
Adjudicator Baird Ellan Recommendations
RR 15-01Constable GomesDelta Police DepartmentNotice of Review on the Record
Constable Gomes Submissions
Commission Counsel Submissions
Chief Constable Cessford Submissions
Adjudicator Filmer Decision
Adjudicator Filmer Decision Appendix 1
RR 12-01Constable JohnsVancouverNotice of Review on the Record
Constable Johns Submissions
Police Complaint Commissioner Submissions
Adjudicator Nimsick Decision
RR 11-03Chief Constable GrahamVictoriaNotice of Review on the Record
Review Management Conference
Chief Constable Graham Submissions
Mr. Dean Submissions
Mr. Dean Submissions Attachments
Commission Counsel Submissions
Chief Constable Graham Reply Submissions
Adjudicator Villiers Decision
RR 11-02Constable Hardy,
Constable Ince
VictoriaNotice of Review on the Record
Constable Hardy Submissions
Constable Ince Submissions
Police Complaint Commissioner Submissions
Constable Hardy Reply Submissions
Constable Ince Reply Submissions
Constable Ince Submissions on Disposition
Adjudicator Filmer Decision - Part 1
Adjudicator Filmer Decision - Part 2