Reviews on the Record

Following the disciplinary process, the Police Complaint Commissioner has the discretion to order a Review on the Record where there is a reasonable basis to believe that the decision of the Discipline Authority is incorrect or it is in the public interest to review the matter.

This type of review is where a retired judge is appointed to conduct a “paper review” of the entire matter, deliver a decision of whether there is misconduct and, if substantiated, determine the corrective and/or disciplinary measures to be imposed. The retired judge’s decision is final and conclusive.

Recommended Procedures (PDF)

Current Reviews on the Record

RR	Members	Departments	Review on the Record Status
23-02	Constable Rajbir Thaper	Surrey Police Service	Notice of Review on the Record
RR 20-03	Sergeant Ajmer Sandhu	Vancouver Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record

Concluded Reviews on the Record

RR	Members	Departments	Adjudicator's Decision
23-01	Special Municipal Constable Foster Martin	Victoria Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record 2023-05-12 Decision on Supplemental Evidence 2023-06-03 Decision on Supplemental Evidence Notice of Oral Submissions Review on the Record Decision Notice of Adjudicator's Decision on Disciplinary or Corrective Measures
22-03	Constable Lance Fraser	Vancouver Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Notice (Oral Submissions) Review on the Record Decision Notice of Adjudicator's Decision on Disciplinary or Corrective Measures
RR 22-02	Constable Arminder Gill	Vancouver Police Department	Amended Notice of Review on the Record Notice of Oral Submissions Review on the Record Decision
RR 22-01	Sergeant Brian Gateley	Combined Forces Special Enforcement Unit of British Columbia	Notice of Review on the Record Adjudicator Threlfall Decision
RR 21-01	Constable Jag Ghuman	Vancouver Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Notice (Oral Submissions) Adjudicator Threlfall Decision Notice of Adjudicator's Decision Regarding Disciplinary or Corrective Measures
RR 20-05	Name Withheld	Abbotsford Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Notice of Adjudicator's Decision
RR 20-04	Constable Neil Logan	Vancouver Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Notice (Oral Submissions) Adjudicator Neal Decision Notice of Adjudicator’s Decision Regarding Disciplinary or Corrective Measures
RR 20-02	Constable Brad Meyer	Victoria Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Adjudicator Lazar Decision
RR 20-01	Special Municipal Constable Rajdeep Mann	Vancouver Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Notice of Adjudicator's Decision Notice of Adjudicator's Decision Regarding Disciplinary or Corrective Measures
RR 19-03	VPD Member	Vancouver Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Review on the Record Decision Letter from the Police Complaint Commissioner to Chairs of Police Boards
RR 19-02	Constable Marty Steen	Victoria Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Notice of Adjudicator’s Decision Regarding Disciplinary or Corrective Measures
RR 19-01	Constable Tyler McCluskie	Vancouver Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision
RR 18-03	Constable Byron Ritchie	Delta Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Constable Ritchie Submissions Commission Counsel Submissions Commission Counsel Supplemental Submissions Adjudicator Threlfall Decision
RR 18-02	Constable Geoffrey Young,	Delta Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Constable Young Submissions on Scope of Review on the Record Commission Counsel Response on Scope of Review on the Record Constable Young Reply Submission of Respondent Officer Adjudicator Lazar Decision on Scope of Review on the Record Constable Young Submissions to Call Further Evidence Commission Counsel Response to Constable Young's Request to Submit Further Evidence Adjudicator Lazar Decision on Constable Young Request to Submit New Evidence Constable Young Submission on Discipline Commission Counsel Reply on Submissions on Discipline Adjudicator Lazor Decision
RR 18-01	Special Municipal Constable Keith	New Westminster	Notice of Review on the Record SMC Keith Submissions Commission Counsel Submissions Adjudicator Neal Decision
RR 16-04	Constable Bunderla, Constable O'Rourke	SCBCTAPS	Notice of Review on the Record Constable Bunderla and Constable O'Rourke Submissions on Scope of Review on the Record Commission Counsel Response on Scope of Review on the Record Adjudicator Oppal Decision on Scope of Review on the Record Adjudicator Oppal Decision on Request for Recusal - Part 1 Adjudicator Oppal Decision on Request for Recusal - Part 2 Adjudicator Oppal Decision
RR 16-03	Corporal McLaughlin	West Vancouver	Notice of Review on the Record Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision
RR 16-02	Constable Gabriel	Vancouver	Notice of Review on the Record Supplementary Notice of Review on the Record Constable Gabriel Submissions Commission Counsel Submissions Adjudicator Oppal Decision
RR 16-01	Constable Thandi	Abbotsford	Notice of Review on the Record Constable Thandi Application to Call New Evidence Commission Counsel Response to Application Constable Thandi Response to Commission Counsel Adjudicator McKinnon Ruling on Calling New Evidence Constable Thandi Submissions Commission Counsel Submissions Adjudicator McKinnon Decision
RR 15-02	Constable Batiuk	SCBCTAPS	Notice of Review on the Record Constable Batiuk Submissions Commission Counsel Submissions Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision Adjudicator Baird Ellan Recommendations
RR 15-01	Constable Gomes	Delta Police Department	Notice of Review on the Record Constable Gomes Submissions Commission Counsel Submissions Chief Constable Cessford Submissions Adjudicator Filmer Decision Adjudicator Filmer Decision Appendix 1
RR 11-03	Chief Constable Graham	Victoria	Notice of Review on the Record Review Management Conference Chief Constable Graham Submissions Mr. Dean Submissions Mr. Dean Submissions Attachments Commission Counsel Submissions Chief Constable Graham Reply Submissions Adjudicator Villiers Decision
RR 11-02	Constable Hardy, Constable Ince	Victoria	Notice of Review on the Record Constable Hardy Submissions Constable Ince Submissions Police Complaint Commissioner Submissions Constable Hardy Reply Submissions Constable Ince Reply Submissions Constable Ince Submissions on Disposition Adjudicator Filmer Decision - Part 1 Adjudicator Filmer Decision - Part 2

Call us:

Toll Free:

Current Reviews on the Record

Concluded Reviews on the Record