Section 117 Reviews

If, following an investigation, the Discipline Authority determines that the conduct of the member did not constitute misconduct, and the Police Complaint Commissioner believes there is a reasonable basis to believe the decision is incorrect, the Police Complaint Commissioner may appoint a retired judge to review the matter. This type of review occurs before any disciplinary process has begun.

If the retired judge determines there is the appearance of misconduct and substantiates the allegation, then the retired judge takes on the role of the Discipline Authority for the continuation of the disciplinary process. If the retired judge determines that the allegation is not substantiated, the matter is final and conclusive.

Recommended Procedures (PDF)

Police Complaint Commissioner Section 117 Reviews

Decision Date	OPCC File	Department	Adjudicator's Decision
2023-02-01	2021-20286	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Hoy Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Conclusion of Proceedings
2023-01-23	2021-19727	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority's Reasons on Disciplinary or Corrective Measures Conclusion of Proceedings
2024-05-06	2023-23655	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2021-08-26	2020-18123	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority's Reasons on Disciplinary or Corrective Measures Conclusion of Proceedings
2023-12-05	2023-23260	Surrey	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Frankel Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2023-12-23	2022-21993	Nelson	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Neal Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Conclusion of Proceedings
2022-09-08	2021-20351	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Neal Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Conclusion of Proceedings
2023-04-12	2022-22042	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pendleton Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2023-09-26	2022-21665	Victoria	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Threlfall Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority's Reasons on Disciplinary or Corrective Measures Conclusion of Proceedings
2023-07-17	2022-22748	Surrey	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2023-03-09	2022-21618	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Arnold-Bailey Decision
2022-08-30	2021-20136	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Takahashi Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2021-06-07	2020-18524	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pendleton Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority's Reasons on Disciplinary or Corrective Measures Conclusion of Proceedings
2022-07-21	2021-19261	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Arnold-Bailey Decision
2022-07-26	2021-20310	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Neal Decision
2022-03-24	2021-19628	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Ehrcke Decision
2021-05-18	2020-17875	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2021-02-17	2019-16335	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Ehrcke Decision
2021-07-08	2020-17317	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Neal Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority's Reasons on Disciplinary or Corrective Measures Conclusion of Proceedings
2021-05-17	2019-16869	Victoria	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Neal Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2021-12-10	2021-19515	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Arnold-Bailey Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2021-04-19	2020-18195	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Lazar Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2021-07-12	2020-17320	Oak Bay	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Lazar Decision
2020-05-21	2018-15597	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Corrigendum to Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision Addendum to Adjudicator Oppal Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Conclusion of Proceedings
2019-09-17	2018-15276	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision on Application for Extension Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority's Reasons on Disciplinary or Corrective Measures Conclusion of Proceedings
2021-09-29	2020-18960	New Westminster	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pendleton Decision
2020-03-26	2019-16226	Vancouver	Notice of Appointment of Retired Judge Adjudicator Neal Decision
2021-01-28	2020-17551	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2020-05-29	2018-14770	West Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pendleton Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority Findings and Reasons Discipline Authority Decision on Discipline or Corrective Measures
2020-02-12	2019-16208	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pendleton Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority Findings and Reasons Conclusion of Proceedings
2021-05-31	2020-18168	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision
2019-10-31	2018-14988	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pendleton Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority Findings and Reasons Conclusion of Proceedings
2020-10-05	2019-16684	Victoria	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Threlfall Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2020-09-08	2019-17122	Victoria	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Lazar Decision Findings of Discipline Authority
2020-09-15	2019-16763	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Neal Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority's Decision on Discipline or Corrective Measures
2020-04-27	2018-14353	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Threlfall Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Disciplinary Disposition Record Discipline Authority's Decision on Discipline or Corrective Measures
2020-07-24	2019-16759	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision
2020-04-16	2019-16656	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator McKinnon Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2019-09-26	2018-14701	SCBCTAPS	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator McKinnon Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2020-06-20	2019-16794	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Lazar Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2019-09-12	2018-15634	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Lazar Decision Findings of Discipline Authority Findings of Discipline Authority Supplemental Disciplinary Disposition Record
2019-07-16	2019-15763	Nelson	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2019-03-19	2018-14498	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision
2019-02-13	2017-13441	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pendleton Decision Adjudicator Pendleton Corrigendum Findings of Discipline Authority Supplement Discipline Authority's Decision on Discipline or Corrective Measures Conclusion of Proceedings
2018-10-16	2018-14290	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision Conclusion of Proceedings-Member 1 Conclusion of Proceedings-Member 2
2018-02-26 2018-04-26	2017-13574 / 2017-13587	Abbotsford / Delta	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pendleton Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2018-02-13 2018-02-21	2017-13493	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Lazar Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2017-10-17 2017-11-03 2017-12-29	2017-13143	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2017-07-26 2017-07-07 2016-11-03 2016-03-22 2016-04-13 2016-04-14	2014-9919	Abbotsford	Adjudicator Oppal Decision Notice of Section 117 Appointment Notice of Appointment of Retired Judge as Discipline Authority Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pitfield Decision Adjudicator Pitfield Decision - Corrigendum
2017-06-29 2017-07-14 2017-10-03 2017-12-13 2017-12-14 2018-01-26 2018-04-25	2016-11867	Vancouver	Notice of Appointment of Retired Judge Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision Adjudicator Baird Ellan Decision - Further Investigation Findings of Discipline Authority Discipline Authority's Findings and Reasons Disciplinary Disposition Record Conclusion of Proceedings
2017-05-23 2017-05-29	2016-12722	New Westminster	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Lazar Decision
2017-05-15 2017-06-07 2018-02-26	2013-8522	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Neal Decision Disciplinary Authority's Findings and Reasons
2017-04-26 2017-05-18	2016-11766	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision
2016-12-07 2017-01-25 2017-03-09	2016-11505	Saanich	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2016-10-05 2016-10-16	2015-11276	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Lazar Decision
2016-07-11 2016-07-28	2015-10371-01	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision
2015-11-26 2015-12-09 2016-06-01	2015-10904	Victoria	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pitfield Decision Discipline Proceeding Decision
2014-12-05 2015-01-22 2015-02-25	2014-9436-03	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal Decision Conclusion of Proceedings
2014-08-15 2014-10-03	2013-9281	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Filmer Decision
2014-03-13 2014-04-02	2013-8589	Abbotsford	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Smart Decision
2013-08-26 2013-10-09 2013-10-10	2012-8138	SCBCTAPS	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pitfield Decision Adjudicator Pitfield Decision - Corrigendum
2013-07-16 2013-08-20	2012-7994	Delta	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Oppal QC Decision
2013-07-17 2013-07-30	2012-7741	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Allan Decision
2013-06-11 2013-06-25	2012-8135	Vancouver	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Overend Decision
2012-12-04 2012-12-19	2011-6366-01	Nelson	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Diebolt Decision
2012-12-03 2012-12-17	2011-6804	Delta	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator de Villiers Decision
2012-04-11	2009-4895-01	Vancouver	Adjudicator Pitfield Decision
2012-03-22 2012-04-04	2011-6633	Saanich	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Lazar Decision
2012-02-28 2012-03-19 2012-11-30	2010-5294	Abbotsford	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Overend Decision Discipline Proceeding Decision
2011-12-08 2011-12-23	2011-6157	SCBCTAPS	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Casson Decision
2011-12-06 2011-12-20	2011-6110	Abbotsford	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Diebolt Decision PCC Requests Judicial Review of Adjudicator Decision (Supreme Court Decision) PCC Appeals Supreme Court Decision (Court of Appeal Decision)
2011-08-02 2011-10-18	2010-5689	Vancouver	Adjudicator Lazar Decision Discipline Proceeding Decision
2011-03-25 2011-04-18 2012-11-22 2012-12-27	2009-4584	New Westminster	Notice of Section 117 Appointment Adjudicator Pitfield Decision Discipline Proceeding Decision - Part 1 Discipline Proceeding Decision - Part 2
2011-01-14	2008-4427T	Vancouver	Adjudicator Pitfield Decision
2010-12-22	2010-5039	Victoria	Adjudicator Lazar Decision
2010-12-13	2009-4542T	Vancouver	Adjudicator Lazar Decision
2010-09-30	2009-4718	West Vancouver	Adjudicator Preston Decision
2010-08-11	2009-4716	Vancouver	Adjudicator Pitfield Decision

Call us:

Toll Free:

Police Complaint Commissioner Section 117 Reviews